Tonight, I watched the movie Shutter Island for the first time. Everyone has always told me I've needed to watch this movie, but somehow I never got around to it until now. I've always loved a good psychological thriller. My favorite movie in this category has always been Silence of the Lambs, however, Shutter Island is now competing for that first place title. I’ve heard from everyone that this movie is amazing, but when I searched the movie on Google, I saw that it only had 68% rotten tomatoes. By the end of the movie, I was both amazed and confused by the low score.
I don't know if I've gotten better at recognizing literary devices, or if this movie, in particular, had a lot more of them, but I found myself pausing the movie every couple of minutes to tell my sister all about the symbolism in someone's dream, the juxtaposition of two characters, or the way that one scene parallels another.
At the end of the movie, Teddy says something that really stuck with me:
Which would be worse: To live as a monster, or to die as a good man?
The weird thing is I don't really relate to this idea, but the movie was so good at capturing my attention and making me feel like I can relate to Teddy even though I’ve never experienced anything like what Teddy has gone through in his life. I feel like I can appreciate the irony of Teddy saying this as a reference to other people on the island when in reality, he is the one who it relates to!!!! Wow, I am getting chills just writing about this.
It is definitely the type of movie that you have to watch a second time to really understand everything, so although I hate rewatching movies because I cant feel the same emotions that I felt the first time, I will be watching this again next weekend.

Wow - I'll definitely watch this movie. I've found that often times the rotten tomatoes score doesn't match up with how good the movie is, especially the score given by critics. The professional watchers are often pretentious and hyper critical.
ReplyDeleteWhile this isn't necessarily the case, one things to account for regarding the discrepancy between your experience and the movies reviews is that objective quality isn't always synchronous with personal enjoyment. I believe a piece of media can be objectively flawed in certain aspects, but still enjoyable to many people.
ReplyDelete